In this course, the word “scientists” is used in a broad sense. According to the Science Council of Japan, the word "refers to researchers and specialists engaged in activities that create new knowledge, or in the use and application of scientific knowledge, in all academic fields ranging from humanities and social sciences to natural sciences, regardless of which institution they belong to." (The Code of Conduct for Sceintists) The first aim of this course is to examine the values which scientists have to share through careful reading of various codes of conduct including those at Tokyo Institute of Technology. Then, by examining real cases of research misconduct and through e-learning (CITI Japan), students learn and understand basic terms and concepts such as "Responsible Conduct of Research," "Questionable Research Practice," and "Research Misconduct," and they not only raise their ethical sensitivity but also acquire problem solving skills by learning the ethical decision-making method called "Seven Step Guide." In addition, through case studies, they examine causes of research misconduct and obtain knowledge and skills to design "research ethics programs" which can be implemented in their respective research environments in order to prevent misconducts and questionable research practice and to promote responsible conduct of research.
By successfuly completing this course, students will be able to
1) explain basic concepts such as "Responsible Conduct of Research," "Questionable Research Practice," and "Research Misconduct" by using concrete cases
2) demonstrate to have fundamental knowledge on responsible conduct of research by completing the e-learning "CITI Japan" course.
3) propose solutions for ethical problems using decision-making methods such as "Seven Step Guide."
4) explain major causes of research misconduct illustrating with real cases.
5) explain the necessity of "research ethics program" and propose such programs which are appropriate to their own research context.
Code of Conduct for Scientists, Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR), Questionable Research Practice (QRP), Misconduct, Research Ethics Program
|Intercultural skills||Communication skills||Specialist skills||Critical thinking skills||Practical and/or problem-solving skills|
This course is conducted in the mode of active learning incorporating group discussions and indivisual presentations. Thus, active participation in course activities is inevitable for successful completion of the course. A hybrid-type e-learning, i.e. combination of e-learning and group discussions, is an important component of the course.
|Course schedule||Required learning|
|Class 1||December 4 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221 1) Course guidance (contents, assigments, and so on) 2) Code of Conduct for Researchers at Tokyo Tech, and other rules and regulations having to do with research ethics at Tokyo Tech 3) Video on research misconduct||Careful reading of the Code of Conduct for Researchers at Tokyo Tech and other documents|
|Class 2||December 11(Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221 11 Lecture on values which scientists should share 2) Lecture on research ethics program||Submit a preliminary report on research ethics program including a candidate institution which will be examined in terms of its research ethics program|
|Class 3||December 18 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221, J231 1) Group discussion on the above case 2) Video on the misconduct case at Bell Research Lab. 3) Group discussion on the above case||Submit a report on the misconduct case at the Bell Research Lab|
|Class 4||December 25 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221 1) Lecture on codes of conduct, rules, regulations, procedures with regard to research ethics at Tokyo Tech as well as safety assuarance in labs and use of plagiarism cheking software 2) Lecture on dual-use issues of science and technology 3) Group discussion on dual-use issues||Submit a report on "The Lab"|
|Class 5||January 8 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221, J231 1) Student presentations on "Good Work" 2) Group discussion on "Good Work" 3) Lecture on RCR education||Submit a certificate to show the completion of the CITI Japan course|
|Class 6||January 15 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221 1) Video on Reseach misconduct (the ES Cell Case in Korea) 2) Group discussion on the above case||Submit a draft on research ethics program report|
|Class 7||January 22 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221 1) Presentation on research ethics programs 2) Group discussion and presentation on the state of research and academic integrity at Tokyo Tech||Submit an evaluation form on research ethics programs of other students Submit a report on research ethics program|
|Class 8||January 29 (Wednesday), 15: 05-16: 35, Suzukakedai J221 Summary and comprehensive Discussion(Discussion among students)||By doing discussion, we will raisthe level of understanding.|
JSPS, For the Sound Development of Science -The Attitude of a Conscientious Scientist-, 2015
JSPS e-learning Course
Japan Science and Technology Agency, "The Lab"
The Report on the Dual Use Issues of Science and Technology by the Science Council of Japan
1) Response Sheets and other assignments (30%)
2) Report on Research Ethics Program (30%)
3) CITI Japan（30%）
4) Participation and contribution to class activities including discussion (10%)
A person who takes the lecture "Ethics of scientists and engineers (course)" needs not attend this lecture.
(Indicate the name and affiliation)
Weekday, 9:00-10:30, 15:00-17:00